Putin knows nobody aside from Xi is likely to launch nukes at him, so he doesn't care about the early warning system. But if he can use this to scare us into giving him Ukraine, he will.
You are probably right in both your assessments, that their system is deteriorating and that this lack of information might make them more nervous and even more aggressive. But I think this detoriation is inevitable. They are corrupt and putting their resources into war, internal security and propaganda and hybrid war towards the West. They don’t have the resources to maintain properly. So the situation is unavoidable over time. To me this means that we have been in the situation for a long time. Russia isn’t able to detect launch. But they know very well that the West will not fire nukes first. Neither will China. And they probably also know, at least fear that their own missiles are not that trustworthy. Neither are their own nukes. So what to do? Bluff and posturing. As they have done for years. Yes, there probably is an increase in risk, and even if I believe that risk is limited it is not zero. And it has increased. So the important task for West is to make sure that Russia know they will not fire first. Otherwise this probably demonstrates something we will see more of. Collapse of various strategic systems in Russia that are not directly linked to the war faring. Am I glad for this? Don’t really know, I simply want Russia to collapse. This is part of it.
You are absolutely right! Unlike the US, which employs a hair trigger "Launch on Warning" doctrine, Russia has deliberately kept their arsenal in a stood down status. Loss of their early warning capability may well cause them to adopt the US doctrine, which will greatly increase the chances of an accidental nuclear war. I went through the numbers on this in a recent post on my Substack stephenschiff.substack.com
How **CAN** Russia launch a replacement? As I understand it, that's Baikonur only, and per recent reporting that facility is down until they have a couple years *without sanctions* in which to repair the damage done to the retractable stuff under the launch pad. Are the Tundra small enough they can use another facility to put them up?
So, the thrust of your argument (the main danger you foresee) is that this inability to see incoming missiles is bad for us because it makes them jumpy. You don't see a problem with this inability to see incoming missiles is bad for Russia because opportunistic actors (EU, anyone?) could take advantage of it and lob nukes toward Russia. I think its pretty bad for everyone either way, but you manage to frame this all through the lens of Russia Bad. Somehow, they are bad because the EU is a demented rabble and that makes them a little wary? I think they'd have good reason to be jumpy these days.
Putin knows nobody aside from Xi is likely to launch nukes at him, so he doesn't care about the early warning system. But if he can use this to scare us into giving him Ukraine, he will.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Soviet_nuclear_false_alarm_incident
May I recommend a book about: nuclear war, a scenario. Annie Jacobsen. Nota bene: I do not get any percentage of the sales. 😅
i cannot see what help russia gives to china, china is more technicale advanced than russia
You are probably right in both your assessments, that their system is deteriorating and that this lack of information might make them more nervous and even more aggressive. But I think this detoriation is inevitable. They are corrupt and putting their resources into war, internal security and propaganda and hybrid war towards the West. They don’t have the resources to maintain properly. So the situation is unavoidable over time. To me this means that we have been in the situation for a long time. Russia isn’t able to detect launch. But they know very well that the West will not fire nukes first. Neither will China. And they probably also know, at least fear that their own missiles are not that trustworthy. Neither are their own nukes. So what to do? Bluff and posturing. As they have done for years. Yes, there probably is an increase in risk, and even if I believe that risk is limited it is not zero. And it has increased. So the important task for West is to make sure that Russia know they will not fire first. Otherwise this probably demonstrates something we will see more of. Collapse of various strategic systems in Russia that are not directly linked to the war faring. Am I glad for this? Don’t really know, I simply want Russia to collapse. This is part of it.
The asswipe handling US nuke codes is Putin’s bitch, so he has no worries about an attack from America.
And yet the invasions happened under Obama and Biden. 🤔
Are Russia’s nukes in the same sorry state as their satellites? ie Lack of maintenance, corruption, degradation. And:
Will someone please give Russia the means to determine it is not under nuclear attack?
You are absolutely right! Unlike the US, which employs a hair trigger "Launch on Warning" doctrine, Russia has deliberately kept their arsenal in a stood down status. Loss of their early warning capability may well cause them to adopt the US doctrine, which will greatly increase the chances of an accidental nuclear war. I went through the numbers on this in a recent post on my Substack stephenschiff.substack.com
How **CAN** Russia launch a replacement? As I understand it, that's Baikonur only, and per recent reporting that facility is down until they have a couple years *without sanctions* in which to repair the damage done to the retractable stuff under the launch pad. Are the Tundra small enough they can use another facility to put them up?
So, the thrust of your argument (the main danger you foresee) is that this inability to see incoming missiles is bad for us because it makes them jumpy. You don't see a problem with this inability to see incoming missiles is bad for Russia because opportunistic actors (EU, anyone?) could take advantage of it and lob nukes toward Russia. I think its pretty bad for everyone either way, but you manage to frame this all through the lens of Russia Bad. Somehow, they are bad because the EU is a demented rabble and that makes them a little wary? I think they'd have good reason to be jumpy these days.