24 Comments
User's avatar
Simon Cast's avatar

I assume you first need to get the MEUs through the Straits don't you? Particularly if they want their toys there to play with.

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

Hi Simon, yes 100%. But one option is an aviation-heavy assault rather than a classic amphibious landing. Marines could, in theory, come in by MV-22s or heavy helicopters from ships or land bases, seize key points, and treat it as a raid or lodgment first, then worry about follow-on sustainment. The problem is that aircraft can move people faster than they can move the mountains of fuel, ammo, air-defense gear, engineering kit, and spare parts needed to hold an island under fire. The CH-53K’s mission radius is about 110 nautical miles, which is useful for regional assault support, though it does not magically solve the sustainment problem by itself.

Another option is staging from Gulf bases already inside the theater and launching a heliborne or small-boat assault from there. That avoids having to push an entire amphibious group through the Strait at the moment of assault. It does not avoid the bigger problem: once you’re on Kharg, you still have to resupply and defend a force sitting within easy reach of Iran’s coast.

Simon Cast's avatar

Airborne would be even riskier and very thin sustainment pipeline.

Robot Bender's avatar

The island is too small to be occupied by Airborne. A lot of troops would end up in the Gulf and likely drown.

Lou's avatar
Apr 7Edited

Well articulated Wes! This is the situation and people need to understand that this guy is incapable of finding a way out of the mess he created to distract from Epstein, satisfy Bibi and his own greedy ego. He could care less what it costs Americans both military and civilian alike. Just pay your taxes and let him spend/steal what he likes. While giving his wealthy buddies whatever they want including Putin.

Jeff Harbaugh's avatar

Now Trump has a war just like Putin's! Neither can get out of their respective wars without having something to show for it.

Cal A. Urquhart's avatar

Our problem is that Iran knows if it does not extract a huge price, Israel and the U.S. will be back again in a few years. They have to make it too costly to ever return. This is obviously the regime‘s greatest moment of vulnerability, but it could also prove to be their greatest moment of opportunity. I fear China will conclude we are weak because we ignore professionals and make emotional decisions.

Chris (CJ Fitz)'s avatar

The president will always be a representative of the American people to the world. The American people are a mixed bag. So how did we pick the very worst of us to be represented? The very, very worst.

Hans Torvatn's avatar

Thank you for this Wes. A clear understandable explanation of why sending the Marines here is even more stupid than «Missisippoli» (did you get around to listen to Tom Lehrer actually? ) It’s sending them to a death trap. Your explanation of why was nice. I honestly don’t think this will happen, because there must be enough experienced soldiers out there who understands this. We shall see. But you had another important point I think many (myself included) haven’t understood. You wrote: «The US way of making war is “alliance warfare.”» That is important. Because it was true in Iraq (a coalition of the willing), true in Libya, true in Afghanistan… true in Serbia too. Before Trump the US presidents have managedto get support from others. Here? Israel, but honestly relative to Iran Israel is not really seeing things straight. And they end up drawing on the same stockpiles. So here we are. Irans civilians will definitely pay the price as will Israeli civilians, Iraqi civilians, other civilians around the Straith. All because of this idiot and his cronies. We Norwegians sometimes says «Uff da» when something bad happens, but here I think we need stronger words. Or prayers. And me an atheist….

G Huck's avatar

We're not taking the island as it would solve nothing and once you take it you have to hold it and that's when the long drawn out conflict begins.

Robot Bender's avatar

I would be very surprised if the Iranians haven't thickly mined most of the island. They've probably brought in IRGC troops and registered their weapons, too.

In an extreme case, they might wire up the oil tanks with explosives. I see absolutely no way we could get on/off the island without huge casualty numbers.

Cabot Thunem's avatar

I notice you did not mention the Iranian stealth underwater drone. The Azhdar. If I were the person in charge of the Jerry Ford, I would claim a problem developed and that I needed to go elsewhere. The Azhdar is not expensive and supposedly they have quite a few. I don't see even getting onto Karg Island without some substantial losses.

Nigel Brazier's avatar

This reminds one of the second world war in the Pacific with those tremendous casualty rates even with Modern equipment and personal armour. I thought this was a Lesson learned and not to be repeated.

Joekipedia's avatar

Hate that it’s gone this way, but perhaps it’s time to destroy the oil infrastructure on Kharg Island, then declare “victory.” It seems like the only way to really deal so much damage to the IRGC that the regime can’t function.

Kenji Troelstrup's avatar

I’m trying to remember the earliest military accounts of what are now called the Straight of Hormuz and Kharg Island. I think it was before Xerxes I, and even then, looking from Egypt and/or Greece, it was regarded as both vital to trade and a very tough strategic nut to crack.

Shades of a land war in Asia…

Simi 🇨🇦🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️'s avatar

The kidnapping of Maduro wasn’t bloodless. The US military killed about 20 people kidnapping him.

Pete Gorton's avatar

I agree. I was going to comment on that but was so impressed with the rest of it, I put it aside.

Will Liley's avatar

What’s new here are the photos of amphibious vehicles. Everything else is the same as it was on February 28, ie, if he wants to take Kharg ships have to run the gauntlet through the Strait and then survive the 300km shooting gallery to even reach the island, and THEN try to avoid 100pc casualties while they sit there in a killing zone that the Ukrainians have demonstrated is a wall of death. Hmmm, don’t think so. And it’s unnecessary: the USN can simply seize every Iranian oil tanker as it exits the Strait into the Indian Ocean, and throttle Iran’s revenue lifeline. I do not doubt for a second Trump and Hegseth’s willingness to sacrifice Marines’ lives for the sake of a Kodak moment but this one would be dumb even for them. He’d do much better to declare victory and go home, leave everyone else to pay $2 million per ship in tolls (about $1 per barrel, ie, nothing, and spin it on Fox News as a big win.

Jeffrey Price's avatar

I’m afraid that there is nobody in our leadership who can or is willing to, stop this madness. Rubio, worthless. Hegs? No tactical or strategic thinking available. Vance? Empty suit. Republican congressmen? Oh please. Nope. We are well and truly screwed. They see the island as an easy target. Like Star Wars - ITS A TRAP!

Chris Fehr's avatar

Is it not plausible that it's covered in mines and explosive devices just waiting for occupiers?