15 Comments
User's avatar
John Schwarzkopf's avatar

Wes, stuff like this is why I became a paid subscriber. That being said, if we can do this to them how do we know they haven't done it to us too? And if companies like Palantir are involved how do we know they aren't for sale to the highest bidder? Much as I dislike 3 letter agencies, they are way better than tech bros.

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

I am in 100% agreement, John. There is a very real danger of the US turning into a tech-autocracy between companies like Palintir, Starlink (SpaceX), Anduril, and others. Unlike the tech 2.0 companies like Facebook and old Twitter, which were largely progressive-run, these new companies are aligned with the far right and have numerous billion-dollar contracts with the DoD. These companies are accumulating power at an alarming rate. They make the CIA and NSA quaint relics by comparison. This website is outstanding for showing the nature of the problem: https://www.authoritarian-stack.info/

Max H's avatar

To play devil’s advocate here just for a minute, let’s ask two questions: what other choice is there, and is this really so different from before? Technology has always been critical to maintaining a military edge over your adversaries. Technology has always been done better by the private sector than by the government. Advanced technology has always been a great source of revenue, the government has always been the biggest customer of military technology. And finally, money has always bought power. The main thing that has changed is that the latest suite of military technology is made up of as much data, AI and software as it is of steel, oil, gunpowder and rudimentary electronics (as it was in the previous generations). Soooo… perhaps nothing much has really changed other than the ingredients of latest military technology? Sure, that puts different private companies at the top of foodchain than the ones that were there two decades ago. But other than that…?

Seldon Crisis Log's avatar

For sure. The tech bros don’t appear to have much loyalty to the United States and have all sorts of escape plans for when shit gets real. Exactly the sort of people that shouldn’t oversee our defense.

Chris (CJ Fitz)'s avatar

So true. Scary, the possibilities.

Richard Careaga's avatar

I have to wonder who has kill switches on us? The more sophisticated the tech, I'd think, the more opportunities for michief.

Robot Bender's avatar

I was thinking the same thing and not just in our missiles.

PhilsThom's avatar

So, Putin pushes the red button and all of his nukes detonate in situ (or in silo)?

Given the Russian proclivities of embezzlement and outright theft, there is a fair chance of this happening anyway.

Chris (CJ Fitz)'s avatar

Blown away by this, I must say.

Hans Torvatn's avatar

Never heard about this concept, but it does make sense. But what do you do if the clock is a quantum computer? Well I guess you would sabotage around it. Every system can of course be sabotaged. Still, if you are prepared there are also countermeasures I guess. Clocks independent on the central clock in flight? Two clocks to compare? But of course the greatest result is probably the uncertainty if you can launch at all.

D.J. Stachniak's avatar

Great article! I’ve been reading your stuff for maybe 2 years now but this is the kind of stuff I like to read and pushed me over the top to become a subscriber. Great work!

Patrick Butler's avatar

Wes.

Hence my concern I wrote to you last, Horowitz increasing stake in Substack, the pattern will be the same.

Not a three letter knock on the door happy with cookies. Your article may launch (it has to land somewhere) but not at its intended target, you may never know, he will control the landing data.

Fortunately there is a beautifully simple solution, it’s coming, be it organically, which takes time……

M

Nola Nowland's avatar

Fascinating

USIBARIS's avatar

does trumpy have his fingers on kill switches

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

I would say no, or at least, I hope not lol