Just a casual observer here, but haven’t we already acknowledged battleships are obsolete? Since we’re here, jet fighters too?
Perhaps not today, but very soon, and if not before the next shootout on the high seas, definitely before any new ships are built.
To this untrained eye, battle ships are massive targets that will be overwhelmed by drones. Thousands of drones, if that’s what’s required.
Ever been in a forest and swarmed by black flies? The little monsters one size up from “no see-ums”? They make mosquitoes seem like a picnic.
I’m from Northern Canada, where black flies are the most insidious pest in the bush. They will make you insane. Literally.
I imagine battleships like I remember myself in the forest, “ignoring” a swarm of black flies. It’s a compromise that can be maintained for a short time, if you’re slathered in Deet, or wearing a net, or both. Ultimately, there’s no solution. No escape. Just insanity or death.
The original concept of the stealth fighter jet was conceived by an officer who wanted small, lightly armed planes, because smaller meant an inherently smaller signature on radar. As to being lightly armed as a consequence of the small size, he explained the virtue as, "Imagine if I entered the Pentagon armed only with a pin, but I were invisible — I could empty the place in fifteen minutes!"
I would suggest that this clunky expensive monster be called The Titanic. It's got a ring to it.
Failing that, he could call it the Moskva, another winning name.
In either case, it would enable Trump to dress up as a Lord High Admiral with lotsa gold braid. And, of course, it would have a below-decks ballroom for major events.
Or it could be called The Gump, with the winning slogan "stupid is, as stupid does."
Sounds like a pretty good argument for an updated Ticonderoga class cruiser (great CVN shotgun, air defender, and power projector... just old). Traditional hulls, updated radar and software. The problem still lies with our expensive missiles for the VLS. Our nation needs a much less expensive and rapidly scalable solution to cheap drones and anti-ship missiles. Perhaps lasers will fill that gap in the near future but you will need a huge power source. Tie the defensive capabilities of lasers with the power projection capabilities of the Tomahawk and I believe you could build a less risky, more cost effective cruiser.
I am not military but intuitively everything you say makes sense. Before I even got a quarter way through reading I was imagining what a target this brute would be, and both the strategic and psychological impact gained by sinking it. It would be so symbolic. To be perfectly frank, it’s a big penis-boat. Trump and Hegseth must love it.
“For $10 billion you could build roughly four to five Flight III Arleigh Burkes.”
I’m definitely in that camp. Sometimes small, agile, and stealth works better than ostentation.
I (grudgingly) admit you have a point. Maybe more than one. But it is absolutely critical that we not screw this up _again_. The US cannot afford yet another shipbuilding failure. If it were up to me, I’d fire everyone at NAVSEA O-6 and above and recall officers, no matter their age, who actually know how to build ships. ⚓️
We cannot protect a Jerry Ford against a stealth submarine. How are we going to protect a large noisy surface target against a fleet of stealth drone dropping stealth submarines. What we need are stealth submarines that can disperse clouds of stealth submarine drones. The biggest rule of combat today is you must be stealthy and quick or you are going to dead very quickly. Yes we might be able to stop incoming missiles but have already proven we cannot find stealth undersea submarines.
I think the best case that is made for this is that it is the "Opener"... this is pitched as an Ego shot, and it gets approved. Then in a few months, someone proposes downsizing it to a Cruiser and saying "We get 90% capability for 30% price" - now it gets approved again because it makes so much more financial sense.
I regret to Congress that this was initially a most entertaining post, with me laughing my fool head off to see Wes O'Donnell confirm my thoughts on this mindless monstrosity... until it became sobering. Wait; this is really what those dummies want to build? Not so long ago, the Navy decided not to build a bunch of Zumwalts, because the Arleigh Burkes were perfectly sound hulls of just the right size and pricepoint, and modern naval might was really about sensors and distributed forces anyway. Now, Trumpipoo wants to please himself with... this easy target?
I love Old Ironsides and agree that it should be the flagship of United States fleet, but it would be about as effective in today's naval warfare as Trump's battleship, if for different reasons.
P.S. — Bath Ironworks is not immediately on the ocean, but is a ways up the Kennebec River. For to the river's depth, the Zumwalt was about as large a ship as it could both build and deliver to the sea. A Chump battleship could not be built there.
All China need do is launch a few dozen or so DF-21 (or similar) missiles at it. The odds are very good that a few would get through. Or in a major war, a few nukes. Either way, that thing is very vulnerable in today's world (as are supercarriers). With enough "cheaper than major naval combatants" missiles...
It's going to be a missile/torpedo magnet and a military budget buster.
Thanks. Case closed then. Sorry… case sunk already. Another stupid unhinged out of this world trump blah blah. That kind of ship will be swiftly dealt with a much cheaper weapon. Underwater smart drones. Or aquaman.
First, your logic seems irrefutable. Second, I so enjoy watching you unpack your thinking. When I read your writing, I want to be on your team. Smart, well-intentioned and sassy as $&@& reading. Thanks for being an honorable voice of reason,,Wes.
My mind is still scarred after seeing that photo where Trump saluted an NK officer who had his hand extended for a handshake - unless it was photo edited.
Wes, as a former sailor, your analysis is spot on. Going down this path would be an enormous waste of money. If it is actually built, which is very unlikely in my opinion, this "battleship" would spend much more time under repair than at sea. And yes, it will be a primary target from day one. At least Trump will make sure it looks good. 😏
Just a casual observer here, but haven’t we already acknowledged battleships are obsolete? Since we’re here, jet fighters too?
Perhaps not today, but very soon, and if not before the next shootout on the high seas, definitely before any new ships are built.
To this untrained eye, battle ships are massive targets that will be overwhelmed by drones. Thousands of drones, if that’s what’s required.
Ever been in a forest and swarmed by black flies? The little monsters one size up from “no see-ums”? They make mosquitoes seem like a picnic.
I’m from Northern Canada, where black flies are the most insidious pest in the bush. They will make you insane. Literally.
I imagine battleships like I remember myself in the forest, “ignoring” a swarm of black flies. It’s a compromise that can be maintained for a short time, if you’re slathered in Deet, or wearing a net, or both. Ultimately, there’s no solution. No escape. Just insanity or death.
But again, untrained observer. 😯
Leslie, everything you said is spot on!
Wow!
. .. ok. I’m signing up for another year. 😉
The original concept of the stealth fighter jet was conceived by an officer who wanted small, lightly armed planes, because smaller meant an inherently smaller signature on radar. As to being lightly armed as a consequence of the small size, he explained the virtue as, "Imagine if I entered the Pentagon armed only with a pin, but I were invisible — I could empty the place in fifteen minutes!"
…and aircraft carriers. Target No. 1
I would suggest that this clunky expensive monster be called The Titanic. It's got a ring to it.
Failing that, he could call it the Moskva, another winning name.
In either case, it would enable Trump to dress up as a Lord High Admiral with lotsa gold braid. And, of course, it would have a below-decks ballroom for major events.
Or it could be called The Gump, with the winning slogan "stupid is, as stupid does."
Titanic was my first thought as well.
Sounds like a pretty good argument for an updated Ticonderoga class cruiser (great CVN shotgun, air defender, and power projector... just old). Traditional hulls, updated radar and software. The problem still lies with our expensive missiles for the VLS. Our nation needs a much less expensive and rapidly scalable solution to cheap drones and anti-ship missiles. Perhaps lasers will fill that gap in the near future but you will need a huge power source. Tie the defensive capabilities of lasers with the power projection capabilities of the Tomahawk and I believe you could build a less risky, more cost effective cruiser.
That's a great point. I didn't consider the missiles themselves in the VLS tubes are way overpriced.
I am not military but intuitively everything you say makes sense. Before I even got a quarter way through reading I was imagining what a target this brute would be, and both the strategic and psychological impact gained by sinking it. It would be so symbolic. To be perfectly frank, it’s a big penis-boat. Trump and Hegseth must love it.
“For $10 billion you could build roughly four to five Flight III Arleigh Burkes.”
I’m definitely in that camp. Sometimes small, agile, and stealth works better than ostentation.
I (grudgingly) admit you have a point. Maybe more than one. But it is absolutely critical that we not screw this up _again_. The US cannot afford yet another shipbuilding failure. If it were up to me, I’d fire everyone at NAVSEA O-6 and above and recall officers, no matter their age, who actually know how to build ships. ⚓️
You had me at ‘Trump recently pitched …’
We cannot protect a Jerry Ford against a stealth submarine. How are we going to protect a large noisy surface target against a fleet of stealth drone dropping stealth submarines. What we need are stealth submarines that can disperse clouds of stealth submarine drones. The biggest rule of combat today is you must be stealthy and quick or you are going to dead very quickly. Yes we might be able to stop incoming missiles but have already proven we cannot find stealth undersea submarines.
May as well call it the Yamato or Bismarck.
I think the best case that is made for this is that it is the "Opener"... this is pitched as an Ego shot, and it gets approved. Then in a few months, someone proposes downsizing it to a Cruiser and saying "We get 90% capability for 30% price" - now it gets approved again because it makes so much more financial sense.
TLDR - this will become a cruiser.
Yep, this is just a scam by the Navy to get a Tico replacement.
I regret to Congress that this was initially a most entertaining post, with me laughing my fool head off to see Wes O'Donnell confirm my thoughts on this mindless monstrosity... until it became sobering. Wait; this is really what those dummies want to build? Not so long ago, the Navy decided not to build a bunch of Zumwalts, because the Arleigh Burkes were perfectly sound hulls of just the right size and pricepoint, and modern naval might was really about sensors and distributed forces anyway. Now, Trumpipoo wants to please himself with... this easy target?
I love Old Ironsides and agree that it should be the flagship of United States fleet, but it would be about as effective in today's naval warfare as Trump's battleship, if for different reasons.
P.S. — Bath Ironworks is not immediately on the ocean, but is a ways up the Kennebec River. For to the river's depth, the Zumwalt was about as large a ship as it could both build and deliver to the sea. A Chump battleship could not be built there.
All China need do is launch a few dozen or so DF-21 (or similar) missiles at it. The odds are very good that a few would get through. Or in a major war, a few nukes. Either way, that thing is very vulnerable in today's world (as are supercarriers). With enough "cheaper than major naval combatants" missiles...
It's going to be a missile/torpedo magnet and a military budget buster.
Thanks. Case closed then. Sorry… case sunk already. Another stupid unhinged out of this world trump blah blah. That kind of ship will be swiftly dealt with a much cheaper weapon. Underwater smart drones. Or aquaman.
Wes
First, your logic seems irrefutable. Second, I so enjoy watching you unpack your thinking. When I read your writing, I want to be on your team. Smart, well-intentioned and sassy as $&@& reading. Thanks for being an honorable voice of reason,,Wes.
Spot on once again Wes.
I think we need to have those huge North Korean officers hats added to Trump's head all the time. Or Dark Helmet from Spaceballs.
My mind is still scarred after seeing that photo where Trump saluted an NK officer who had his hand extended for a handshake - unless it was photo edited.
Wes, as a former sailor, your analysis is spot on. Going down this path would be an enormous waste of money. If it is actually built, which is very unlikely in my opinion, this "battleship" would spend much more time under repair than at sea. And yes, it will be a primary target from day one. At least Trump will make sure it looks good. 😏