22 Comments
User's avatar
billy mccarthy's avatar

so much fora president of peace who demands a nobel peace prize

James Grand's avatar

… so the US has everything, in fact. Except surprise and, more than that, they know how you’re going to do it. Going to be expensive for someone, somewhere. Just because the US is shooting in the Gulf doesn’t mean Iran will. Personal view: this has the makings of a huge and completely pointless mistake: No military gain + terrible loss of life on both sides + an unsettling loss of military credibility. Oh yeah: and the unfortunate “Israel’s poodle” thing (but you know that already).

Iconoclast's avatar

Israel demolished the Gaza Strip. Hamas is still in power.

Ronald Levin's avatar

Hamas has stopped rocketing Israel. Hamas hasn’t launched a land raid killing 1200 civilians and ki dnappong 250 civilians —despite a years old ease fire— since oct 7, 2023. Now Israel has a much wider frontier zone to protect the Israeli border from future invasions . The destruction of Gaza is sad but the United States would do no less if 1200 Americans less if Americans were killed and killed and 250 kidnapped — and you damn well knew that’s true

Iconoclast's avatar

You totally missed the point.

We are not sending troops into Iran. The most we will do is destroy infrastructure and assassinate some leaders.

My point is that Israel did the same in Gaza but has been unable to dismantle Hamas.

What are the odds that the US will have better success in Iran?

Ronald Levin's avatar

Thanks for the reply. Yes, I understood no ground to be there. We learned our lesson in Iraq and Afghanistan. We can flatten a regime, but cannot erect a replacement. I dont think anyone including the long suffering Persian people are able to establish a replacement, even if somehow they rid themselves of the evil Mullahs.

My guess is that 80%+ of the Iranian population would like to get rid of the Regime, but there is no organized opposition, the Crown Prince has no organization in Iran and there is no alternative leadership they all have been murdered,

f we "obliterate" their nuke system (again...) and this time their ballistic missile production...that will be victory enough even without regime change,. Publicly The Gulf Arabs oppose this war, but i believe most of the Kings, Emirs and Sheiks quietly support any effort to eliminate the constant risk of Iranian aggression, destabilization, and dictation. The EU too will be delighted to be rid of the threat of Iranian mid range Ballistic Missiles which can now hit parts of Eastern and Southern Europe.

I know a bit about Iranian history, and i understand why the "Supreme Leader' is resolute against giving up nuke production, ballistic missiles, and proxies. But these no longer protect Iran, instead they are a magnet for American sanctions and interventions. If the regime could be replaced, ia successor govt could rid of nukes and BM and proxies to take a big step toward defending itself from the US and getting rid of sanctions -- the only way to fix a nearly dead economy. Ennormous othe problems remain: water shortages in the cities, poverty, electricty shortages, and terrible pollution. R11

Will Liley's avatar

Wes, bring on the coming article about Iran sinking a carrier. China will be watching with interest. Would a missile be able to actually sink the Roosevelt or the Ford, or just severely damage them? I’m thinking back to the Pacific War in WW2, or to the 1982 Falklands War when Argentina sunk the huge Atlantic Conveyor and a British frigate using Exocet missiles.

Jack Carter's avatar

Burning tax payers (and stupid foreign treasure bonds investors) money by bucketloads. Easy. One trillion more on the american debt for the next administration. Lol

Robot Bender's avatar

With the amount of Chinese missiles Iran has on hand, it's possible one of more ships will be hit if they launch a salvo. One missile hit could easily sink an escort ship. Remember HMS Sheffield during the Falklands War? That was a hit from an Exocet. Imagine a ship that size being hit by a Silkworm or other Chinese missile.

Sugarpine Press's avatar

Wes, is the need for Growlers obviated by 5th Gen capabilities? Noticed their absence from the list.

Another Dave's avatar

Why rely solely on stealth when you can shut down all of their sensors and also be stealthy?

Edward Bryant's avatar

Some Growlers are intrinsic to the carriers, are they not?

Fleet Logic's avatar

There should be a squadron of Growlers on each carrier.

Arent's avatar

Thank you for this article. Learning a lot from your experience and knowledge. US gunboat diplomacy relies on CSG strategy. That hasn't changed for decades. Just how vulnerable are the carriers for massive drone and missile attacks?

BG Pete Chiefari's avatar

Thanks, Wes! Excellent post!

Doug Girvin's avatar

Didn’t the UK say no to US use of Diego Garcia?

BG Pete Chiefari's avatar

Yes they did! I read about it this morning.

Ronald Levin's avatar

Amd now, a week later i have to revise my opinion "no troops on ground".

Most of us worry that Trump's war will mire us in the Near East again. That is my second biggest fear.

Not my first.

My first main fear is that the Islamic Regime is ready. Iran has known for two weeks that Trump ordered the 31st MEU and its 3,000 to 5,000 Marines and sailors to the Gulf. And for the past 45 years, the Regime has known that sooner or later one MEU or another or maybe a dozen MEU's, probably, would steam into the Gulf.

If Marines land on the oil terminal, Kharg Island, they will be standing on the world's largest Shahed target. If they assault the Shahed launch sites on the Gulf's northern littoral, they will face 900 miles of Zagros Mountains and cliffs with hidden Shahed, missile and gun positions dug into the rock. Expect a reprise of Omaha Beach, but much longer than just "one longest day."

Trump may have ordered the 31st MEU to the Gulf not to seize ground but just to pressure Tehran. Yet, when the Marines arrive and the IRGC is still rocketing Israel and the Gulf Arabs, still blockading the Strait of Hormuz, when faced with no other alternative to end the stand off, what will the ever-impulsive Trump do? To protect his frail ego and maintain his enduring charade of masculine strength, won't Trump order the assault?

R 11. hoc fecit

Napoleon's Colonel's avatar

Looking forward to seeing the sinking carrier paper.

Darryl Darwent's avatar

Thank you for the informative article.

Hans Torvatn's avatar

Thank you for this. Never a dull moment, but what about reducing the numbers to three per day? Or something similar. But I guess the math adds up to a prolonged series of strikes. Unless a deal is struck, but I doubt it.