15 Comments
User's avatar
David Facer's avatar

The unreliability/unpredictability of the current US administration is moving Canada toward ITAR-free defense sovereignty. Ukraine and Iran are teaching basic economics to anybody still in love with exquisite weapons systems.

Craig Smith's avatar

David, while I agree that Canada should move towards ITAR free weapons we have a long way to go. As Wes mentioned, we just spent billions on HIMARS. The RCAF is shows no inclination to move away from the F35. We just had an RFP for night vision binoculars where there was a last minute change so that only American suppliers qualified. The mentality of the CAF working as a subsidiary of the Americans is deeply imbedded in military culture. We constantly hear that military to military relationships are great which is fine until the White House moves from taking aggressive action against our economy to taking action against our military in whatever form. The military seems to take a “no need to worry I’m ok” approach.

Scott Carter's avatar

Yes, as much as I loathe the idea, it is time for our government to tell the Forces “sorry this is where we’re headed. Get used to a lot of non-American kit. Considering the tariff hammer falls tomorrow, we need to ITAR proof ourselves and protect Canadian IP as well.

David Facer's avatar

I see Canada attempting a smooth branch swinging maneuver: F35s now while they build Gripens and GoldenEyes. HIMARS now while they build low cost autonomous drones.

Paul's avatar

One more lesson we're taking away from Ukraine - don't rely on the US for any weapons system where they can exert leverage. The F35 also falls right into that bucket.

Graham Nolan's avatar

One more 'can it do this?' question Wes and maybe it depends on the prevailing winds between Russia and Canada - can the long-range strike option handle being lofted 60000 feet up on a weather balloon that could significantly extend its range? Or if the wind generally blows Russia-to Canada do they have anything cheap that can see and shoot down weather balloons? Because you can bet the soviets are dying to use that sneaky trick on somebody.

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

Interesting thought, Graham. In theory, starting a weapon at 60,000 feet gives it an energy advantage, but balloons are lousy precision launch platforms. Stratospheric winds generally run west to east, which also makes Canada-to-Russia balloon geography somewhat uncooperative. The reverse problem is more interesting. High-altitude balloons are cheap and awkward to deal with. We know an F-22 can kill one with an AIM-9X, because we did that in 2023. So: possible conceptually, messy operationally, and absolutely something NORAD planners have reason to think about.

NYKIndependent's avatar

FirePoint is not an entirely Ukrainian enterprise. It has been largely western funded, and worked extensively with Western engineering, aerospace and defense firms as well as militaries developing its weapons So “Ukraine” is a bot misleading. Like all other contractors, they also want to become totally indigenous. But that takes time. Ukriane has a five year head start.

Scott Carter's avatar

Thanks for an excellent article, Wes. Yes, slide over the Gordie Howe anytime! You are helping us Canadians keep up with our defence matters. Never has so much planning, policy and funding has occurred ever in Canadian defence in such short a time!

Oh and singing “God Save the King” is a nostalgic tribute that means very little now, IMHO.

I’ll proudly sing that song composed by Calixa Lavallee and words courtesy of Adolphe-Basile Routhier and Robert Stanley Weir.

MJVD's avatar

Worth noting that whatever system is selected for the phase 1 IOC of 2027 might not be the system that is continually procured long-term. The CAF wants deep strike yesterday and knows Canadian industry can not build something from scratch that fast. So it may be a Ukrainian system for the 2027, with on-going competition in the medium term and different system procured into the 2030s.

Or the CAF may think whatever they get in phase 1 is great and scale production of that system.

The other piece (on the high-end) of the long-range fires is PrSM(3). Canada has requested it and it's pending approval by the State Department. The CAF is pretty keen on PrSM(3)'s anti-ship capability from a HIMARS launcher in the Arctic. They would like to be able to rapidly deploy (fastwr than sailing a ship) anti-shipping to the high north and be able to have more persistance/time on station than air craft can offer.

Craig Smith's avatar

The logic of loading a HIMARS launcher onto a transport and flying it into the arctic to launch a missile escapes me. Surely must be a better way.

MJVD's avatar

If you know you're going to launch immediately, yes you'd likely use an air-launched missile. If you want to hold an area, a ship, an approach to the North West Passage, etc at risk for an extended period and aren't sure when or if you'd actually need to launch, then the land-based launcher is the mosy useful.

Susan Woodman's avatar

I’m wondering if the lack of temperature specifics comes from the anticipated threat being to the south of us rather than the arctic. In which case the temperature range will match what Ukraine’s systems have been adapted to.

Jan Mouchet's avatar

Very good article mr O'Donnell!

Great data and interesting.

I keep in the f16 airframe life span, is worst than a su24 older than many soldiers or a mig 29 still singing red army chorus songs?

Earth's avatar

Reuters link is broken.