52 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Harmon's avatar

And, maybe someday those weapons systems can be turned into plowshares, instead of becoming better swords.

Well presented technical information presented in an understandable manner. Much appreciated!

mfmatusky's avatar

Thank you for bringing that into the discussion! War is better prevented than fought. Feed us humans well, keep us fat and happy, and we're much less likely to fight.

JasonT's avatar

There is no history that supports that happy thought.

mfmatusky's avatar

I'm not sure if you're claiming that fat and happy people, generally with jobs and girlfriends would still rather wage war rather than enjoy peace or if you're claiming that once radicalized and waving AK-47s it takes more than a productive job and a loving relationship to get a radical to give up fighting. Can you clarify?

I'd also be pleased to hear your level of experience, training, and how much time you've spent among cultures prone to taking up the proverbial AK.

Brian Rosen's avatar

We’re actually much like Hobbits.

mfmatusky's avatar

I read an article by a columnist who practically embedded himself with one of the "Muslim terrorist" organizations for what might have been years. His recommendation as to what those guys need to keep them from being a radical horror show with AK-47s? Jobs and girlfriends.

Rob Lawson's avatar

Hopefully we do zero till agriculture and we can turn them into other useful things.

Scientist at the bench's avatar

The utility of drones, coupled to new portability of artillery would completely change the battlescape. Expensive systems should be a thing of the past. The potential utility of this tech in tanks would also change tht system to one lighter, more agile and faster.

BG Pete Chiefari's avatar

You have to love digital technology! Excellent; easy to understand even for a guy like me! Thanks, Wes!

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

Pete, I’m blessed with a smart audience

Craig Ewing's avatar

Well, maybe not smart in some ways, Wes. I had to Google 'butter bar' and 'Rip-its'. Otherwise, a well-told tale of a significant and on-going evolution in artillery technology. My only question is if the upgraded version jointly produced by the US and India will be available to Ukraine. Neither country is exactly on its side right now.

Jan Mouchet's avatar

Really interesting dossier, thanks!

Robert C Culwell's avatar

Thank you for the Physics Wes

Great work.

Fire and Maneuver, FAST.

John Schwarzkopf's avatar

"A Humvee, by comparison, weighs about 5,500 pounds unloaded. Asking it to absorb the recoil of a 105mm cannon is like asking your elderly grandma to tackle a pro NFL player."

I love that analogy!

Dorian's avatar

Everyone is watching missiles.

Almost nobody is watching logistics.

That’s usually where military revolutions actually happen.

A howitzer on a Humvee sounds like a meme until you realize what it represents:

cheaper deployment,

faster repositioning,

lower logistics burden,

higher survivability under drone surveillance.

Modern warfare is increasingly becoming a race between detection and relocation.

The side that can fire and disappear fastest wins.

Soft recoil technology is interesting not because it changes artillery.

It changes the economics of artillery.

And military history is full of examples where cost curves mattered more than weapon specs.

mfmatusky's avatar

Cool! One question- If the barrel spring packs up a veritable ton of spring energy under compression behind some kind of sear to jack the barrel foreward at the right split second, what happens if the barrel is NOT caught on the sear with the spring under compression (no spring energy to release)? I expect there would be some sort of "cocking" mechanism (think crossbow) to compress the spring to get it ready to fire. Is that correct? Any info? Top secret?

When these things are "parked" out of action is the spring released to keep it from taking on a "set" under compression?

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

Dang, my readers keep me on my toes. Okay, mfmatusky... Great question, and the patents and technical documentation actually answer most of it.

The "spring" is a gas spring, meaning a hydropneumatic accumulator charged with gas under pressure, not a mechanical coil spring. That important for the storage question because gas springs don't take a "set" the way metal springs do. Gas doesn't permanently compress. The seals are the vulnerability in long-term storage, not the spring itself. So the system can live in the cocked position without that concern.

On normal cycling: it's self-cocking. The Mandus patent is explicit. When the round fires, the residual rearward energy drives the barrel back, recompressing the gas spring. The latch then catches the barrel at the rear and holds it there, spring charged, ready for the next round. Every shot re-cocks the system automatically. That's part of the elegance.

For initial cocking from cold, the AUSA 2025 coverage mentions a hand crank wheel specifically added for degraded-mode operation, which suggests that's the manual cocking mechanism. Crossbow comparison is apt.

For the misfire scenario, the Mandus patents include a dedicated misfire recovery system with what they call a "misfire buffering phase." If the barrel is running forward and the round doesn't fire, the system has to arrest that forward motion safely without slamming the barrel into the stops and sending full conventional recoil into the Humvee chassis.

They engineered a buffer specifically for that scenario.

The cookoff concern is also documented. If a round fires while the barrel is still in the latched position rather than during the run-up, the system behaves more like a conventional howitzer and the platform can become unstable. The fire control system manages sequencing to prevent that, but it's a known edge case they've had to design around.

Whew

mfmatusky's avatar

Thank you Wes! Yes, seals on gas springs are a vulnerability but I'd bet dollars to donuts the hydro-pneumatic spring "parks" with oil around the seals (think shock absorber or liftgate spring that is installed with the rod, NOT the tube, pointing downward. Oil is far easier sealed than air (or perhaps a large-molecule inert gas).

Jim Jarvie's avatar

In the same context, I would imagine that there is a fair recoil from the initial spring powered barrel ejection ,that would result in a 'double tap' scenario, although very close together.

Or am I not seeing something? The barrel would be much heavier than the munition; to get that moving with enough speed to dampen the full recoil, would have a recoil effect of it's own.

Jim Jarvie's avatar

And the recoil of the barrel comes back with exactly the same force that ejected it, to reload the spring and latch mechanism. Where has any of the recoil been lost? It's only been slowed down by micro seconds.

Robert Honeyman's avatar

If the system absorbs 60% of the recoil, that would suggest that the hydraulic release and reset is less than or equal to 40% of the total energy being generated by firing a shell.

Fraser Barnes's avatar

This can also have a major impact on naval warship design, giving smaller off shore patrol vessels far more fire power.

Reiner's avatar

Are you sure the m777 weighs just 4000 pounds? Seems more like 4000 kg.

stakx's avatar

Yes, ~4000 kg is what Wikipedia says for m777. Also, it's a bit disingenuous of author to compare the weights with 155mm guns. These are weapon systems for different situations. For example, the M119 howitzer, still in service, is towed and ~5,000 lbs/2,320 kg (Wikipedia).

Other considerations are important, too. Some pointed out gun accuracy. Also include maintenance as more moving parts = more service.

Bernhard Guenter's avatar

Hi Wes, and greetings from Koblenz! I live here and didn't even know we had an arms museum. We do have a big monument of Kaiser Wilhelm II, an accomplished war criminal, and the Fortress Ehrenbreitstein from which he ran WW I. And then there's me who refused to serve in the army, and would much prefer a world in which arms aren't even needed. But to quote the Stones, "You can't always get what you want.".

Fred's avatar

What I want to know is, has anyone tried building a big gun with an integrated regenerative braking system? Use the momentum of the cannon propelling forwards to generate stored force that is spent on dampeners to soak up the force of the return journey (to baseline firing position). Because that feels like exactly what we should be doing.

Do that in combination with this SRT and then you can put that on a 155 millimetre.

Dominik Lenné's avatar

Interesting. But i see one problem: precision. A shot with the barrel not moving can be precise, even if the vehicle is somewhat wobbly. A heavy barrel being pushed forward with great force will make the vehicle move in unpredictable ways and produce large error ellipses. With only a few shots available, target destruction probability goes out of the window.

BG Pete Chiefari's avatar

Good comment, Dominic! But I think that in the development stage, any CEP effect could be accounted for.

Dominik Lenné's avatar

Actually, this vehicle is not as wobbly as I thought. If you look at the picture, you see two vertical hydraulic supports at the "bow" and two slanted ones at the "stern", which may make the Humvee a pretty stable platform. Disadvantage: time needed to lower/rise those.

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

I think there's some good footage from United24 Media of Ukrainians firing it. I'll try to dig it up.

mfmatusky's avatar

It seems that's the difference between a mobile artillery platform and a tank.

Robert Honeyman's avatar

Software solves accuracy. And as you note below, mechanical stabilizers increase stability. It should take little time to release and raise the stabilizers.

THE EASTERN SOCIETY's avatar

Interesting piece, I've seen pics from WW2 with anti tank guns mounted on Jeeps but not this sort of thing.

Jacob Gee's avatar

The concept is similar to an open bolt MG or SMG, which have been around along time without a need for precision ignition beyond what a basic mechanical system can provide. based on the drawings it appears the put momentum onto the entire gun and not just a bolt/recoil element. A con of this system has always been introducing some shot dispersal, which is going to be magnified a lot over 11 km, and if the whole gun is moving. I assume the precision electronic ignition you mentioned is needed to deal with shot dispersion in this setup, to get it down to acceptable levels.

This begs the question: how likely are we to see this technology applied to accurize open bolt S/MG?

Christopher J O'Shea V's avatar

@Wes O'Donnell: Well played. SF

Donald Hill's avatar

Hey, some of us noticed this two years ago. Why are we nobody?

Good explanation.