Anything Trump authorizes in support of Ukraine is just him wiggling his tiny mushroom dick to prove to Putin that he is 'powerful' and 'strong' and not the weakling coward he really is. He will always side with Putin when push comes to shove because he is the bottom in that bromance
I suppose it does make sense that CIA is helping-have capacity for very high flying intelligence gathering and technical no how. I really think that Ukraine needs to go into overdrive and hit Putin where it hurts…good article.
JFC Wes, posts like this make my paid subscription to you my most important Substack subscription!
I don't know how you get your information, but it's the best out there. Although I'm having a hard time believing Diaper Don would let the CIA go against his Russian handler who clearly has kompromat on him. Your thoughts on that?
Thanks John. I have to tell you, I had to quit my corporate job in November (that I’ve had for 10 years) because it was impossible to lead a large team while studying for the bar exam. So your paid subscription, along with my Medium and YouTube earnings, are keeping me alive while I write and study. So, 🙏 I personally thank you.
Wes, best of luck with the bar exam - which state? I noticed your were in NYC over the holidays; was that just a visit? I echo JS - yours is my favorite, and it’s a much-needed counter to the gloom-and-doom narratives about UKR’s inevitable forced surrender. Maybe, just maybe, Trump is beginning to realise he’s been played by Putin and that his desired Nobel Prize is more likely by supporting UKR than by cow-towing to Russia…and earning the Chamberlain-like condemnation of history.
That's a good question; one that I should have probably addressed somewhere in the piece. It’s almost certainly intentional, and it’s aimed more at Moscow than at the public.
First, controlled leaks are a tool. When senior officials allow something like this to surface, especially through outlets like the Telegraph or New York Times, it’s usually because they want the message out without issuing a formal statement. That preserves deniability while still shaping behavior. It could also be leverage signaling. By letting it be known that US intelligence helped identify refinery choke points, Washington is quietly telling the Kremlin that the campaign can continue or expand if Moscow refuses to move. Maybe the hope is to push Putin to negotiate. Just some guesses.
Helpful hint: Ukrainians are not stupid. It is they, and there, that did the specialized machining work in Soviet times. In Kharkiv, for example, so it didn’t take the very special geniuses of Foggy Bottom to puzzle out how an oil refinery works.
“Couplings” as a specialized word that no one knows? Oh, puhlease. Choo-choo trains are joined by a kind of coupling. So, when the kiddos are playing with the train set in the basement, even the girlchildren learn such big words.
True, the oil industry is different, but every other industry has its own parts, tools, methods, too.
Here’s another historical factor that puts Ukrainians in the know about what is built where and how it works: the USSR still is within living memory. If not sent to build such projects as forced labor, there is another means by which Ukrainians were to be found across that vast country: the Soviet government assigned college graduates to where they would spend their lives working. Make your life and family there, and too bad if you prefer to stay at home in Ukraine—off you went and no fair whining.
That means that by having grandfathers serving in the military provides Ukraine with the scope of experience of those who worked all across Russia back in the day.
The imposition of the Russian language for however many years means that infiltration is that much easier facilitated by this compelled linguistic familiarity.
Also, Russians themselves are starting to protest more than just when on their knees. Sabotage by their own is becoming a thing again there.
GPS and night vision and good ole atlases that back in the day showed the location of places like Polyarnyy—well, cities and buildings and suchlike facilities don’t move very far when doing such specialized work as done there, as an example of sites shown in Cold War-era atlases, although oddly not in more recent editions. Why? Rand McNally’s got some “‘splainin to do to Luuucy.”
When Elon played on again/off again with Starlink (a factor the US should keep in mind before having him and his restructure our Internet—just saying—Ukraine had to fall back onto Bellingcat and other OSINT outlets for satellite imagery. Well, zoom in on your weather app to see the undulations of field and forest globally or peek at Google Earth to watch people *as they shop inside stores*, and extrapolate.
Oh, and intelligence help comes also from other nations appalled by the Puppet Factor, who know they are next on Vova’s Wish List.
If the CIA has been helping Ukraine—thank you most sincerely! But there has been a trend of stolen valor from Ukrainians’ hard-won successes lately in US Defense publications. They like to both brag and build big here in the US, but find they can no longer overlook the capabilities of drones to take out ships, tanks, radar systems, trains (at the couplings, sometimes!), etc.
So, respect to the innovative Ukrainians, who are doing the job we funded the DoD all these decades since 1917 to accomplish. (:-))
History is replete with examples, both large and small, of the Underdog reshaping the Battlespace. While
intelligence is critical, the best intelligence in the world is virtually useless without the ability to execute.
Ukraine’s thinking outside the box coupled with their ability to execute is redefining the modern Battlefield as well as, in this instance, the Battlespace. The U.S. is getting more than their moneys worth in return for the shared intelligence.
The only way couplings would be that critical would be if the equipment on one side or the other originates in the USA and is manufactured in obsolete dimensions.
Even then, Russia should be able to make them reasonably easily - even threads with pitches defined in "threads per inch" can be cut fairly easily on a lathe if you have a 127 tooth change-gear available. (127.000mm = 5.0000 obsolete length-units).
Most Chinese lathes ship with such a gear for this very purpose.
If splines defined in obsolete units are required they could still be made on modern machinery, albeit only by a skilled machinist. It would take a bit of time - first, someone needs to do a bit of careful measuring and arithmetic, then a machinist will have to deal with annoying dimensions such as 9.87mm +/- 0.043.
The initial Ukrainian focus on “nice explosions” makes perfect sense to me. Short term priority needed to be given to destroying the fuel depots that were supplying the attacking forces. Without doing that, there might be no future. Only after sufficient attrition of those could attention afford to be switched to strangling Russian ongoing capacity to produce fuel. Which also makes perfect sense.
See the raid on St. Nazaire, the commandos trained for weeks to precisely place explosives on the most hard to replace machinery, etc deep down inside identical British dry dock facilities.
Using an obsolete destroyer as a massive demolition tool was another bit of brilliant British daring. No one knew if the reinforcements around the destroyer turret would stop the ship or not. But they did and so the explosives hidden deep down in the ship disabled the doors of the lock that the ship had been rammed into.
Afterwards, that port could no longer be used for large German warship repair. The commando losses were sobering, however.
Without fighting over the choice of the nomenclature being "couplings," where are these "couplings" made? Historically, have the Russians made them or imported them from abroad? Can they readily make them today, although doing so may take time, or must they learn how? Can they manufacture the necessary tools and materials? Presumably, some couplings are easier to make than others.
The importance of these couplings is entirely credible. A system pumping pressurized, explosive liquids must be perfectly sealed. Anything that disrupts the seal must be eliminated: vibrations, the subtlest misalignments or corrosion. The "couplings" link ordinary industrial machinery (motors, pumps, turbines, and the like) to the dangerous parts that are designed to run steadily, and are not easily stopped or started.
I am reminded about how, during World War II, the Americans and English sabotaged a German heavy water plant that was central to the German push for nuclear weapons. The saboteurs were given strict instructions to ignore almost everything in the plant. They were to focus all of their destructive capabilities only on some glass tubes at its very center, the one part that the Germans could not easily re-fabricate.
Anything Trump authorizes in support of Ukraine is just him wiggling his tiny mushroom dick to prove to Putin that he is 'powerful' and 'strong' and not the weakling coward he really is. He will always side with Putin when push comes to shove because he is the bottom in that bromance
I suppose it does make sense that CIA is helping-have capacity for very high flying intelligence gathering and technical no how. I really think that Ukraine needs to go into overdrive and hit Putin where it hurts…good article.
Now, how do you hit the factories that contain the precision tools and personnel to make those highly specialized parts? (Evil grin)
JFC Wes, posts like this make my paid subscription to you my most important Substack subscription!
I don't know how you get your information, but it's the best out there. Although I'm having a hard time believing Diaper Don would let the CIA go against his Russian handler who clearly has kompromat on him. Your thoughts on that?
Thanks John. I have to tell you, I had to quit my corporate job in November (that I’ve had for 10 years) because it was impossible to lead a large team while studying for the bar exam. So your paid subscription, along with my Medium and YouTube earnings, are keeping me alive while I write and study. So, 🙏 I personally thank you.
As for Trump, maybe it’s a lovers’ quarrel? 😆
Wes, best of luck with the bar exam - which state? I noticed your were in NYC over the holidays; was that just a visit? I echo JS - yours is my favorite, and it’s a much-needed counter to the gloom-and-doom narratives about UKR’s inevitable forced surrender. Maybe, just maybe, Trump is beginning to realise he’s been played by Putin and that his desired Nobel Prize is more likely by supporting UKR than by cow-towing to Russia…and earning the Chamberlain-like condemnation of history.
i also find it hard to believe that the taaco guy would help zelensky out
Any idea why American officials would inform the press of this CIA assistance?
That's a good question; one that I should have probably addressed somewhere in the piece. It’s almost certainly intentional, and it’s aimed more at Moscow than at the public.
First, controlled leaks are a tool. When senior officials allow something like this to surface, especially through outlets like the Telegraph or New York Times, it’s usually because they want the message out without issuing a formal statement. That preserves deniability while still shaping behavior. It could also be leverage signaling. By letting it be known that US intelligence helped identify refinery choke points, Washington is quietly telling the Kremlin that the campaign can continue or expand if Moscow refuses to move. Maybe the hope is to push Putin to negotiate. Just some guesses.
Helpful hint: Ukrainians are not stupid. It is they, and there, that did the specialized machining work in Soviet times. In Kharkiv, for example, so it didn’t take the very special geniuses of Foggy Bottom to puzzle out how an oil refinery works.
“Couplings” as a specialized word that no one knows? Oh, puhlease. Choo-choo trains are joined by a kind of coupling. So, when the kiddos are playing with the train set in the basement, even the girlchildren learn such big words.
True, the oil industry is different, but every other industry has its own parts, tools, methods, too.
Here’s another historical factor that puts Ukrainians in the know about what is built where and how it works: the USSR still is within living memory. If not sent to build such projects as forced labor, there is another means by which Ukrainians were to be found across that vast country: the Soviet government assigned college graduates to where they would spend their lives working. Make your life and family there, and too bad if you prefer to stay at home in Ukraine—off you went and no fair whining.
That means that by having grandfathers serving in the military provides Ukraine with the scope of experience of those who worked all across Russia back in the day.
The imposition of the Russian language for however many years means that infiltration is that much easier facilitated by this compelled linguistic familiarity.
Also, Russians themselves are starting to protest more than just when on their knees. Sabotage by their own is becoming a thing again there.
GPS and night vision and good ole atlases that back in the day showed the location of places like Polyarnyy—well, cities and buildings and suchlike facilities don’t move very far when doing such specialized work as done there, as an example of sites shown in Cold War-era atlases, although oddly not in more recent editions. Why? Rand McNally’s got some “‘splainin to do to Luuucy.”
When Elon played on again/off again with Starlink (a factor the US should keep in mind before having him and his restructure our Internet—just saying—Ukraine had to fall back onto Bellingcat and other OSINT outlets for satellite imagery. Well, zoom in on your weather app to see the undulations of field and forest globally or peek at Google Earth to watch people *as they shop inside stores*, and extrapolate.
Oh, and intelligence help comes also from other nations appalled by the Puppet Factor, who know they are next on Vova’s Wish List.
If the CIA has been helping Ukraine—thank you most sincerely! But there has been a trend of stolen valor from Ukrainians’ hard-won successes lately in US Defense publications. They like to both brag and build big here in the US, but find they can no longer overlook the capabilities of drones to take out ships, tanks, radar systems, trains (at the couplings, sometimes!), etc.
So, respect to the innovative Ukrainians, who are doing the job we funded the DoD all these decades since 1917 to accomplish. (:-))
This is some outstanding Anthony Cave Brown goodness. Well done, Wes and keep piling on.
The one decent thing you did.
Great article! Thanks.
History is replete with examples, both large and small, of the Underdog reshaping the Battlespace. While
intelligence is critical, the best intelligence in the world is virtually useless without the ability to execute.
Ukraine’s thinking outside the box coupled with their ability to execute is redefining the modern Battlefield as well as, in this instance, the Battlespace. The U.S. is getting more than their moneys worth in return for the shared intelligence.
The only way couplings would be that critical would be if the equipment on one side or the other originates in the USA and is manufactured in obsolete dimensions.
Even then, Russia should be able to make them reasonably easily - even threads with pitches defined in "threads per inch" can be cut fairly easily on a lathe if you have a 127 tooth change-gear available. (127.000mm = 5.0000 obsolete length-units).
Most Chinese lathes ship with such a gear for this very purpose.
If splines defined in obsolete units are required they could still be made on modern machinery, albeit only by a skilled machinist. It would take a bit of time - first, someone needs to do a bit of careful measuring and arithmetic, then a machinist will have to deal with annoying dimensions such as 9.87mm +/- 0.043.
The initial Ukrainian focus on “nice explosions” makes perfect sense to me. Short term priority needed to be given to destroying the fuel depots that were supplying the attacking forces. Without doing that, there might be no future. Only after sufficient attrition of those could attention afford to be switched to strangling Russian ongoing capacity to produce fuel. Which also makes perfect sense.
See the raid on St. Nazaire, the commandos trained for weeks to precisely place explosives on the most hard to replace machinery, etc deep down inside identical British dry dock facilities.
Using an obsolete destroyer as a massive demolition tool was another bit of brilliant British daring. No one knew if the reinforcements around the destroyer turret would stop the ship or not. But they did and so the explosives hidden deep down in the ship disabled the doors of the lock that the ship had been rammed into.
Afterwards, that port could no longer be used for large German warship repair. The commando losses were sobering, however.
You wrote: «The valuable contribution would be intelligence that helps answer questions like:
Which units inside a refinery are truly critical path right now?
Which train is running, which train is in maintenance, and which one is already limping?
Which spare parts are on site, and which are not?
Which facility has the most painful constraints under sanctions?
Where are the high value choke points that cause cascading downtime?»
I agree. Such questions tells you what to try to target. But is it possible to target so precise?
Without fighting over the choice of the nomenclature being "couplings," where are these "couplings" made? Historically, have the Russians made them or imported them from abroad? Can they readily make them today, although doing so may take time, or must they learn how? Can they manufacture the necessary tools and materials? Presumably, some couplings are easier to make than others.
The importance of these couplings is entirely credible. A system pumping pressurized, explosive liquids must be perfectly sealed. Anything that disrupts the seal must be eliminated: vibrations, the subtlest misalignments or corrosion. The "couplings" link ordinary industrial machinery (motors, pumps, turbines, and the like) to the dangerous parts that are designed to run steadily, and are not easily stopped or started.
I am reminded about how, during World War II, the Americans and English sabotaged a German heavy water plant that was central to the German push for nuclear weapons. The saboteurs were given strict instructions to ignore almost everything in the plant. They were to focus all of their destructive capabilities only on some glass tubes at its very center, the one part that the Germans could not easily re-fabricate.
K
Very interesting detail indeed, thanks Wes 👍