29 Comments
User's avatar
Mark G Buell's avatar

I think the bit you were missing in 2014-2022 was just how deep the Russian prejudice against Ukraine runs. I learned of this while doing expat work in Russia, and it really surprised me. I didn't see it as virulent, but it was deep and persistent. Ordinary Russians really think Ukraine is Nazis. It was as deep a misunderstanding as the American misunderstanding of Iraq was.

Thank you for all your analyses. While I did not see the seriousness of Putin's military actions until after the 2022 invasion, it immediately became apparent to me that this was today's equivalent of 1937 in Spain. I completely agree with the global significance you have outlined here. Glad to see people saying it out loud. Thank you again.

Wes O'Donnell's avatar

Mark, that’s a really important point, and I think you’re right. I underestimated just how normalized that prejudice was inside Russia, not as frothing hatred, but as a steady, state-fed assumption that Ukraine isn’t real, isn’t sovereign, and must be “rescued” from itself. That kind of belief doesn’t need to be virulent to be dangerous; it just needs to be widespread and unchallenged. I appreciate you sharing that perspective, and I’m glad you said it out loud.

serghiy's avatar

…it’s not just Ukraine, putin declared war on the west in 2014 and NOBODY did shit about it and now YOU HAVE IT

…”The Long, Destructive Shadow of Obama’s Russia Doctrine”

A series of bad decisions during the Obama years prepared the ground for Vladimir Putin’s war.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/07/11/obama-russia-ukraine-war-putin-2014-crimea-georgia-biden/

Mark G Buell's avatar

You may be right. It is not sure. In 2014 what I saw was how Russia had handled the Georgia conflict. Namely, take a little territory as "contested". Most in the US didn't even think about it at all. My thinking, as far as I could tell, was extreme. But it was honest, and in 2014 it appeared to be valid. Russia was viewed, generally, as an economic opportunity. They could bring themselves into the egalitarian theory behind the western economic sphere. That would mean economic opportunity across classes. For a while, this actually happened. But the US blew the opportunity by not adequately supervising aid projects. Russian systems were inherently corrupt, as they had to be under the Soviet, in order to survive. American aid projects did not manage corruption well. American projects were not a whole lot better.

As a result, Russians experienced a very brief blossoming. But it didn't get widely recognized, because the blossoming was from the bottom up. That kind of growth takes years to get recognized.

Anyway, Obama didn't make that many "mistakes". Mistakes (of this sort) were pretty much endemic in the US/EU culture of the time. Do I think mistakes were made? Yes. But that is in hindsight. And, while hindsight may be 20/20, foresight is scattershot.

serghiy's avatar

…rusha is a GENETIC GARBAGE, it’s not derogatory it’s what happens when throughout the whole history of the country and last century they literally exterminated all intelligent and free thinking people generation to generation and only people left who oppressed them or those who kept their mouth shut in order to survive, that country always was full of criminals, not much to lose there, we used to say if someone got locked up, they got from a “big prison” to a “small” one, major problem of putin’s country that it HAS NO HUMAN RESOURCES to build society that makes sense for the rest of the world, its all gone with all those republics, which they were milking all through the soviet years, to become their own sovereign entities, which infuriated putin, a country of people who never ever think of their future because everyone knows nothings good is coming tomorrow,

…soviet union forcefully inbred stupidity and putin finished it off

…dreadful place in and out, Ukraine on the other hand is different, but it’s three times smaller population then rusha and its loses are very unequal not by quantity, but by quality of loses with future potential to rebuild their country, any war is a horrible thing, specially for the nation that did not want it, but have to face it and spend precious resources not on making their people live better, but for the simple task to survive, FUCK putin ! …GLORY TO UKRAINE 🇺🇦 !

serghiy's avatar

…rusha was never a good partner, putin is a gangster presiding over mafia state, what business opportunity anyone can have with gangsters - trump

…”Russia: The

mafia as the state

MUNIRA MUSTAFFA

Prigozhin’s death is only the latest

example of an enigmatic fusion of formal

governance and clandestine networks.”

https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/russia-mafia-state

John Schwarzkopf's avatar

I don't know why a blue collar high school graduate who has read a lot of WWII and pre-WWII history can see that Putin is doing exactly what Hitler did, and if Ukraine falls the rest of Europe will be next. Russia definitely can't be trusted on anything and neither can the US. We've proved again and again that treaties mean nothing. Just ask any Native American.

Carmen Kazakoff-Lane's avatar

The comparison goes even deeper.

Ukraine is Czechoslovakia. When Hitler got Czechoslovakia, he got their manufacturing infrastructure that meant Germany could double its war manufacturing.

Ukraine has food,rare minerals, technology. Should Russia get its hands on it, Russia would become twice as deadly.

Ukraine must not fall. If it does, the following war will be World War III.

Scott Carter's avatar

I now understand why your beliefs are so personal with regard to Ukraine and its future. Why can’t the “so called diplomats” Witkoff and Kushner read your article and gain the proper insight. Of course, they know all this and couldn’t care less pertaining to their transactional goals. History will ultimately treat them very cruelly and accurately. And your president will be included.

Johnny Goodham's avatar

From your lips to God's ear.

Craig Ewing's avatar

Thanks for this, Wes. It is a heartfelt yet clear-eyed reflection on Russia's criminal actions. It's too bad the post-WWII order wasn't more specific and adamant that the end of that war meant the end of empires (it should have been more clearly stated after WWI). We seem to have forgotten the meaning of national sovereignty and how it is the fodder for any country that sets itself to empire-building. The world appears to have lost the plot and Russia, China, Trump's America, Israel and perhaps a few other places are resurrecting this once-obsolete abuse of power. We can stop it now or we can stop it later - but later will be a disastrous conflagration.

TanyaFella's avatar

Passionate and logical. Thank you ... I agree.

MICHAEL'S CURIOUS WORLD's avatar

No-one is safe if Putin is allowed to conquer Ukraine.

Will Liley's avatar

“…a simple, stubborn belief that nations have a right to decide their future”. YES! YES! You have never written such a profound and powerful polemic. It’s inspiring. Chamberlain was pilloried after the fact for selling the Czechs to the Nazis in 1938 (comfortably after-the-fact) but he recognised an uncomfortable reality: he needed to appease Hitler to give Britain time to re-arm, especially its Air Force (and it was a close-run thing two years later in 1940) and whatever its “great power” weight, Britain (&France) were militarily powerless to stop Hitler’s move against the Czechs. The time to stop Hitler was in 1936 when he moved to re-occupy the Rhineland. The Wehrmacht at the time had 100,000 troops; France had 1.2 million. But it was so traumatised by the carnage of WW1 and so riven by politics with the extreme catholic right hating the Blum socialist government, that it dithered and did nothing, and the moment to puncture Hitler was lost. Why the history lesson? Because as Wes says, if we don’t stand up now, our grandchildren will have to face this. It’s beyond distressing that Vance, Don Jr, and Witkoff are so cynical about UKR but of course, they merely reflect the wishes of their fuehrer.

Jungle Pyramid Washer's avatar

Well let’s all look on the bright side. The worst that might happen is human civilization is erased and we lapse into a situation resembling that found in Cormac McCarthy’s novel “The Road”.

Speaking of my friend Cormac, I also recommend his book “The Crossing”, though the forewarned reader must be prepared mid novel when Cormac reveals man’s true nature in a way that is sure to leave you morally devastated.

Paul Drake's avatar

Thanks Wes. That piece is beautifully written, and poignant.

Paul S's avatar

You thought you knew Russia because you studied Russian literature and history. What you didn’t realize, but should realize now, is that you fell for the Russian con, the one that created Ruskiy Mir, the one where the KGB cultivated most all Russian history professors at American universities (while usurping and stealing the Ukrainian identity). I fought this at Georgetown university in the 1980’s which at least was a conservative institution compared to Harvard and Colombia the other two leading Russian schools. Russian literature is nihilistic and feeds the death cult that is Russia , so called Russian culture is like a zombie feeding off others brains, Tchaikovsky was made up entirely of Ukrainian peasant melodies for his leitmotifs, and even the architecture is stolen form Kyivan Rus. Without Ukraine they are simply the Mongol Horde. Time to re learn your history and see the so called culture through a new lens

Pete Gorton's avatar

Wes, many of us are exactly aligned with your thinking. Its not Russians we're wary off, its the Russian "government's" lust to expand its long-dead empire. The shear brazen effrontery is breathtaking, aided and abetted by the completely morally - and ethically-wanting Trump regime. UA MUST survive - intact, and be a key part of Europe/UK/Canada etc.

Shawn M Ryan's avatar

In a nutshell, Trump and his ilk support Russia because they hope to develop similar conquests abroad and wish to normalize this type of national behavior. The consistent theme coming from Trump’s words and deeds is, anything goes. There are no rules for winners. Take everything you can from anyone who is not willing to fight. Indiscriminate attacks against anyone who doesn’t toe the line is the norm for Putin and Trump and things will only get worse if the other two branches of government don’t grow a conscience soon. The new world order that MAGA seems so intent on issuing in will be a brutal, dangerous disaster for all but the most well off and insulated.

The crisis in Ukraine has already had far reaching consequences. Things will only get worse, exponentially worse, if we don’t step in and step up. That will only happen if we neuter the feral dog in the White House through court sanctions and a huge turn out in ‘26 at the polls. Only a Democratic congress can stop the madness. Reversing the domestic and international damage MAGA has already caused will take years of concerted effort but this is possible. It all starts with people being engaged and knowledgeable. Read multiple sources and then contact your representatives at the state and federal levels. Then make sure to vote up and down the ballot. There are no unimportant positions. Local boards, school boards, County representatives etc. are all important.

So yes, Ukraine is important but without representation from top to bottom here in the U.S. it’s value may not be realized until it is too late.

On another note, Go Bears!

Al Bell's avatar

Your blatantly clear description of what is actually at stake in the Ukraine is clarity at its most precise level. It is the kind of insight that simply cannot be ignored and, to do so, is insane. Ignoring it is also an exercise in gross irresponsibility in light of what the World learned in the last century about how fragile the balance of peace is—and must remain if we are to survive the atrocities of history magnified by the tools of destruction now at our command.

Three of your statements particularly stay with me--so profoundly that I have included them in my file of imported wisdom that is a repository for ideas I must have access to at will; it is where my brain goes to recall what it is obliged to remember accurately:

It [The invasion of Ukraine] was a naked bid to overwrite sovereign choice with imperial ambition.

A “peace” that legitimizes conquest is a strategic pause in a much larger plan.

And that’s the problem with trust. Once it’s gone, even a sincere proposal looks indistinguishable from a setup.

I am grateful for the insights you have shared; would that they could be shared on the global stage and impressed upon its actors who deem themselves our leaders.

Robert W Moses's avatar

Thanks for this Wes. Europe knows the fight is now in Ukraine or later on their borders. I was in Russia in 2000 and noted their attitude - that they owned Ukraine. After studying Ukraine I felt it was Russian resentment that Ukrainians have done much better with their society and innovation, even during the later Soviet times.

What do you think of Zelensky's call for an "air shield"? I wrote a story on it in Medium. I'd love your take on it and maybe expand a bit more on it.

The Dead Rabbits's avatar

Seems like scare mongering. When Russia starved the Ukraine, killing millions, the New York Times applauded in its pages. They proudly display the Pulitzer on their walls today. In fact Russia ruled the entire Ukraine for 70 years and nobody cared. Even Obama let those “little green men” walk in and take Crimea. I not going to lose sleep over the evil Russians coming down my street anytime soon.