Satellite communications or long haul network infrastructure proves its use with control of sea drones, etcetera.
The issue for me is who owns the aforementioned and who can disable it? As PM Carney indicated after the Starlink/Starshield interference by “someone” in the USA this incident to Ukraine’s detriment “can’t be unseen”.
"Britain has now invested 113 million pounds in the company making them"
I'll have to come back and read later but this sentence stood out; When nations "invest millions" in such things where does the money go? I am concerned that in many cases it goes to make a small number of business leaders quite rich. We need to do these things for the right reasons, not to make businessmen rich (or stockholders dividends).
"The company expects to create hundreds of skilled jobs". Getting better but it's likely somebody is still getting rich...
"Defence procurement is difficult enough without insisting that every useful idea be invented in Whitehall first". As a contract engineer one of our principles was "Let the customer have all the good ideas". Sometimes they even recognized we added substantial value...
This sum is small in comparison to some of the eye-watering amounts paid for the likes of a few F35s for instance, or the cost of refitting the catapults on the UK's carriers! I would expect most of this development money to actually be used in development, especially in a small, new company. The problem you refer to will most likely come in a number of years' time when they have a proven product and a steady pipeline of orders. That is when the likes of BAE will move in, offer a boat-load (pun intended) of cash to the owners and within a year will suddenly find a few design flaws that will need a major redesign and cost the MOD £3BN. That is probably where you should be looking.
Thank you Graham. In retrospect I reacted to 113 million without thinking that, in context, it isn't a large sum. Thank you for gently recognizing that there is a problem even though it isn't yet happening right here in this case. We do seem to be doing it a LOT here in the U.S. With billions.
This raises an interesting question about the course of the war, counterfactually. If the US and its then allies had given Ukraine full conventional weapons support in the first year, would the war have been won? What if the Russians had somehow learned to do what the Ukrainians did instead, which was to put the New Warfare doctrine into practice on an accelerated design, develop, produce, train, and deploy schedule? Which side in that hypothetical scenario would you rather be on?
If the U.S. and allies had backed Ukraine with full conventional weapons support and the war didn't grind on for years the losses taken by Russia would not have taken place. It is unfortunate but putting Russia in its place (trouncing V. Putin) would have been much harder/more destabilizing than allowing them the opportunity to flush so much "blood and treasure" down the drain. Just a thought.
To go just a little farther, the slowly growing dissatisfaction among average Russians (AND among Russian oligarchs) permitted by the long, grinding, war is actually a major force in bringing the war to a close. With optimism and hope I imagine (mostly the oligarchs) rising up in Russia to work towards war's end and closure. They'll do it for money, but we will all benefit.
Good point. With necessity being the mother of invention had the west dumped "full conventional weapons support" into Ukraine early on Ukraine likely wouldn't have developed much of their means to fight.
Hey Wes, that funny salute; it’s a British Army thing from WW1. With the introduction of broad-brimmed helmets doing a conventional salute collided with the brim. The Royal Navy, being the senior service, said “we’ll keep the traditional salute thank you very much”.
Thanks much for the transcript, Wes.
A good article, Wes.
Satellite communications or long haul network infrastructure proves its use with control of sea drones, etcetera.
The issue for me is who owns the aforementioned and who can disable it? As PM Carney indicated after the Starlink/Starshield interference by “someone” in the USA this incident to Ukraine’s detriment “can’t be unseen”.
"Britain has now invested 113 million pounds in the company making them"
I'll have to come back and read later but this sentence stood out; When nations "invest millions" in such things where does the money go? I am concerned that in many cases it goes to make a small number of business leaders quite rich. We need to do these things for the right reasons, not to make businessmen rich (or stockholders dividends).
"The company expects to create hundreds of skilled jobs". Getting better but it's likely somebody is still getting rich...
"Defence procurement is difficult enough without insisting that every useful idea be invented in Whitehall first". As a contract engineer one of our principles was "Let the customer have all the good ideas". Sometimes they even recognized we added substantial value...
This sum is small in comparison to some of the eye-watering amounts paid for the likes of a few F35s for instance, or the cost of refitting the catapults on the UK's carriers! I would expect most of this development money to actually be used in development, especially in a small, new company. The problem you refer to will most likely come in a number of years' time when they have a proven product and a steady pipeline of orders. That is when the likes of BAE will move in, offer a boat-load (pun intended) of cash to the owners and within a year will suddenly find a few design flaws that will need a major redesign and cost the MOD £3BN. That is probably where you should be looking.
Thank you Graham. In retrospect I reacted to 113 million without thinking that, in context, it isn't a large sum. Thank you for gently recognizing that there is a problem even though it isn't yet happening right here in this case. We do seem to be doing it a LOT here in the U.S. With billions.
This raises an interesting question about the course of the war, counterfactually. If the US and its then allies had given Ukraine full conventional weapons support in the first year, would the war have been won? What if the Russians had somehow learned to do what the Ukrainians did instead, which was to put the New Warfare doctrine into practice on an accelerated design, develop, produce, train, and deploy schedule? Which side in that hypothetical scenario would you rather be on?
If the U.S. and allies had backed Ukraine with full conventional weapons support and the war didn't grind on for years the losses taken by Russia would not have taken place. It is unfortunate but putting Russia in its place (trouncing V. Putin) would have been much harder/more destabilizing than allowing them the opportunity to flush so much "blood and treasure" down the drain. Just a thought.
To go just a little farther, the slowly growing dissatisfaction among average Russians (AND among Russian oligarchs) permitted by the long, grinding, war is actually a major force in bringing the war to a close. With optimism and hope I imagine (mostly the oligarchs) rising up in Russia to work towards war's end and closure. They'll do it for money, but we will all benefit.
My thought was that Ukraine would have been fighting the war that the Russians were prepared to fight.
Good point. With necessity being the mother of invention had the west dumped "full conventional weapons support" into Ukraine early on Ukraine likely wouldn't have developed much of their means to fight.
Thank you for this. I hope the Norwegian defense minister learned from the demo! I think we could do with a couple of those in different versions.
Interesting.
How does the Magura compare with the Australian Ghostshark?
Are they similar or different?
Hey Wes, that funny salute; it’s a British Army thing from WW1. With the introduction of broad-brimmed helmets doing a conventional salute collided with the brim. The Royal Navy, being the senior service, said “we’ll keep the traditional salute thank you very much”.